Hi Nalway,
First off, congrats on your AF week and losing weight! Well done! It feels good, doesn't it?
The rest of your post is heart breaking! I have a lump in my throat as I write. Unfortunately, I don't have enough time right now to read back in your thread to see what else you've said about your daughter and to know how you feel about AA, so I'm going to jump right in and give my opinion in the sincere hope that I won't offend you.
I personally wouldn't go to AA and I wouldn't advise your daughter to go either. AA teach helplessness, they teach that we are incapable of managing our own lives, that we are 'alcoholics' this becomes our definition, we have to identify with that, they teach that we can't control our drinking. Basically, we learn that we are an inferior sub-group of people, a group apart, we're not normal... And that any accomplishments we might achieve are due to external factors - a higher power...
I think that's a very harmful and unhealthy attitude to have, it's destructive because it leads to a self-fulfilling prophesy. After a few failed attempts at the unrealistic goal of total abstinence, the person stops making an effort because they think: what's the use, I'm a hopeless case anyway, I'm an incapable, pathetic alcoholic, I might as well destroy myself. They make little effort to take control of their situation because they don't believe they can, because they've been taught that they can't.
We should be learning self-respect and self-reliance. We should be learning that we
can control our lives, our drinking and our habits. We should be learning that just because we have made some bad choices in our lives that we are
not doomed to continue that way. We should be learning that we
can change, we
can grow, we
can progress.
We are normal, capable human beings, and just like everyone else on this planet, we make mistakes and we go through rough patches, and just like everyone else, we can overcome our problems, we are capable of turning things around. We, the individual, me, not a higher power or a group of strangers, me. We badly need a sense of self-worth, self-reliance and self respect. AA does the exact opposite.
Have you spoken to her about Naltrexone? Has she been to therapy? I'd recommend Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) or Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT).
Self-efficacy is a critical component of behavioral therapies, they teach people that they have the capabilities and competence to manage their own lives. Any success is attributed to the person and reflects back on their self-image; failure helps people learn how to improve their self-management skills and rebuild their confidence, be it for her drinking, gambling or anger.
This book might be helpful:
http://peele.net/7tools/index.phpAs for, should you let her move back home? Well, that's a tough call, on the one hand, she is your daughter after all, so you're hardly likely to leave her on the streets, but on the other hand, some boundaries need to be set. Maybe you and your husband could draw up a 'contract' with her, the 3 of you work it out together, a list of things that are unacceptable for all of you??
I wish you all the best!
Curi