AndMoreAgain wrote:
Maybe I’m being naive but I’d still like to be able to “tie one on” once in a great while for some special occasion and experience those silly, raucous moments with close friends.
You're expressing a basic fear that a lot of us have -- what if alcohol is what enables our sociability, our ability to 'let go' and get silly now and then? What if alcohol stimulates one's creativity (think of Ernest Hemingway at the typewriter with his glass of whiskey), and then the magic elixir is taken away? Does the quality of life go to hell?
On one hand, most drunks probably are not nearly as charming and entertaining as they think they are. So the loss may not be as great as one fears.
But in my case, being socially awkward and tongue-tied as a teenager was an important reason that I started drinking. Alcohol allowed me to be loose, jokey, glib, gleeful -- all the things that I wasn't, as my sober-sided self.
Everything is a compromise. To escape the addictive and health-damaging effects of alcohol, one may have to sacrifice the brighter side of it as well. This issue still bothers me, but I'm prepared to face it.